About Medical Alert Systems: Learning Module

Medical Alert Systems are conceptually simple. You press a button and help comes.

But when it comes down to choosing one, it turns out there are quite a few subtleties that one needs to take into account to be sure of choosing the best medical alert for a given person.

This site includes various reviews and articles about different medical alerts. To get the most out of reading the material, you really need to know which types of features you actually want.

This Learning Module contains several different pieces of content designed for people with different levels of familiarity with the topic of personal emergency response systems.

It consists of:

• a recorded lecture on medical alerts, and
• a tutorial on the basics.

Lecture & Workshops

When we first developed this medical alert learning module we created a rather detailed online workshop.

However, we have found people prefer either:

• (a) an actual hands-on, face-to-face workshop; or
• (b) a lecture they can watch at their convenience.

If you represent a group that wants either a face-to-face workshop or an in-person lecture, feel free to reach out and explore the possibilities.

• Contact us to explore a workshop or lecture to your community.
• To watch a recorded lecture, read on.

Recorded Lecture

For most readers, a recording of a lecture (with slides) is a great way to get an overview of the medical alert system topic.

Here is a relatively recent video recording of a lecture on medical alerts given by Dr. Richard Caro in 2022.

View and Listen to the Seminar

Abstract

Medical Alerts are well known “safety” devices. However there are many different types, and there are very few resources to help decide which type is best. Tech-enhanced Life has for years been evaluating different products in this category. While we do not believe there is such a thing as a “best” medical alert, we do think there are often a handful of “best” products for specific individuals (the right features depend on lifestyle).

In this talk, we will explain how to decide which type of medical alert is right for a specific person, and introduce you to the detailed coverage on Tech-enhanced Life that will enable you to pick a specific product that works for the person in question.

Deep-Dive Articles Mentioned in the Talk

Medical Alert Systems Guide (The “Hub”)

“Just Tell Me What to Buy”

The Five Personas

Smart Watch as Medical Alert?

Additional Lectures

If you want more, we have recorded lectures (audio plus slides) of Dr. Richard Caro presenting to one of the Chicago “Villages” on: Summoning Help in an Emergency: Devices; Emerging Trends; and to the Washington DC Villages on “How to Choose a Medical Alert System”.

If you would like to watch these lecture (it’s free), follow the link below.

• View Dr Caro’s Lectures: on How to Choose a Medical Alert, and some emerging products for “Summoning Help in Emergency”.

Tutorial: The Basics

An Emergency Response System (medical alert system) includes some type of button you press, or automatic sensor that detects you have a problem. When you press the button or the problem is identified, the system somehow sends a message to a “responder” and then that responder takes some action.

The Responder

There are quite a few different approaches to how these systems are implemented. In the most common approach the “responder” is a call center operated by or on behalf of the company that makes the medical alert system. So when there is an emergency, the system “calls” the call center where there is a person whose job it is to take action. This approach is called a “monitored” system.

There are also systems that are “unmonitored“. In that case, you set them up so that in emergency the system calls a number you tell it in advance, or sends an email to people you designate in advance. The typical scenario is that you program it to call a friend or family. Or perhaps 911. Or perhaps an escalating call tree, starting with friends and then going to 911 if no-one answers.

What Happens in Emergency

When an emergency is detected (most typically when you press the button on the alert system), the system calls the responder. Some responders will just send emergency services right away (ie dial 911). But the more sophisticated responder services will call the older adult who is having an emergency and try and find out what is going on before taking further action.

Ideally, the older adult gets a call from a responder who says “Are you OK Mrs Smith? How can we help you?”. Some services will provide a range of response services. For example they might call the towing company if you have broken down, or call an ambulance in a real emergency, or just stay on the phone while you walk through a bad neighbourhood if you are feeling unsafe.

Fall Detection Algorithm

As of Jan. 2024 when this was last updated, many medical alerts incorporate a fall detection algorithm.

This is in our opinion an important feature. The way it works is that there is a sensor built in to the product that can detect if you fall over. When it detects a fall it first asks you if you fell and if you are OK. But if you don’t respond it automatically calls for help, in the same way it would if you pressed the button.

This is a very important feature if you worry about falling and hitting your head, or having some type of cardiac event or stroke then falling.

Of course, these algorithms are not perfect, and sometimes lead to false alarms. Thus it is important to get one of the products that include the ability to talk to you and check it is a “real” fall.

The Sensor / Button / Wearable

A medical alert system is only useful if it can actually summon help in an emergency. Typically, these systems have some type of pendant or wrist-worn device that has a button on it. The older adult is supposed to press the button in case of emergency.

Some pendants are designed to include a fall autodetection capability, and can automatically contact the responder when they detect a fall. One needs to consider what happens in case of a false alarm for one of these automatic systems.

A modern approach to designing a medical alert system is to make the whole system an “App” on a smart phone. In this case, instead of a pendant you just need to press the button on your smartphone.

The ergonomics and cosmetic appeal of the sensor/button/wearable is critical, and what works for one person may not be right for another. After all, if the sensor is not within reach in emergency you cannot press the button. Ideally the sensor/button would work everywhere, and be in some form factor that means you have it on at all times. Most systems fall short of this ideal and so one needs to make tradeoffs.

In some products, the medical alert is part of a smartwatch, in which case the sensor / button is part of the smartwatch.

The Different “Types” of Medical Alert System

We think of these systems as falling into several distinct types (“flavors”). Picking which type works for you is an important first step in selecting one.

Works at Home Only

The original medical alert systems, designed decades ago, were designed to have a base station that attaches to a person’s home phone line, and talks with the pendant/button via some type of wireless signal. There are many of this type of system still being sold, and some have been updated to include more modern and robust technology, but still with this basic “at home” concept.

Of course, this type of system will not work at all once you go far enough away from the base station so that the pendant can no longer communicate to the base station. While some systems will allow you to go into the yard, once you head off to the shopping center the system will no longer be protecting you.

Within this category, there are two sub-types of system. One sub-type has a base station that connects to the responders via a landline. The alternate approach has a base station that connects via a cellular connection.

Works “Everywhere”

An alternate concept has the pendant (or perhaps some additional “portable base station” communicating to the responder via cell connection. This approach has a big advantage in that it “works everywhere”. The tradeoff is that these systems typically are larger and more bulky.

Furthermore “everywhere” is a term that needs definition. These systems will work “everywhere” that the system can get a cell signal from the carrier that the system uses. So if it is hard to get a cell signal in your bathroom, the system might not work there. And if you live in the country where cell coverage is poor, it will not work there either.

In theory, these systems could work in multiple countries. In North America, most of them only claim to work in the USA — or perhaps in the USA and Canada.

Form Factor of the “Wearable”

The traditional approach to the medical alert system is to have some type of “wearable” that is attached to the body of the older adult using the system. For example, this could be in the form of a pendant or of a wrist watch type wearable.

The alternate approach is to have the “wearable” be a smartphone, with the idea that some people have their smartphone with them at all times.

Smartwatch as Medical Alert

A relatively recent trend is for a medical alert functionality to be incorporated into the form factor of a smartwatch.

This has a big advantage in that the appearance of these products is much less stigmatizing than a conventional medical alert. You can read more about the pluses and minuses of this type of medical alert here:

• Read “Smartwatch as Medical Alert”.

Who is the First Responder?

As explained above, the system may be monitored, in which case the responder is a person in a call center. Or the system could be unmonitored, in which case the system contacts either a friend or emergency services (by dialling 911 directly).

Questions About You to Answer Before Deciding

There are a series of questions to ask yourself, relating to which of these various types of system will work best for your circumstance. We have built a selection tool to help turn the answers to these questions into a short list of “products that should work for your circumstance”. You can access that tool on the main page of this “Guide”. Follow the link further down the page. And when you get to the main Guide page, look for “Selection Tool”.

Return to the Guide: Medical Alert Systems

Click on the button below to return to the main page summarizing our research results on medical alert systems.

Medical Alert Systems: Selection Guide